ChemistryExam code: 4CH1

Carboxylic Acids

Organic Chemistry

  • Carboxylic acids behave like the inorganic acids met in topic 16: they donate a proton (the H of the O–H) into solution, and they react with the same partners — metals, bases and carbonates — to give a salt as one of the products

Naming the salts

  • A salt formed from a carboxylic acid ends in "-anoate" instead of "-anoic acid"
  • The pattern:
    • Methanoic acid → methanoate salts (HCOO−)
    • Ethanoic acid → ethanoate salts (CH3COO−)
    • Propanoic acid → propanoate salts (CH3CH2COO−)
    • Butanoic acid → butanoate salts (CH3CH2CH2COO−)
  • The cation (sodium, potassium, calcium, ammonium, etc.) is named first, exactly as for inorganic salts

Reaction with reactive metals

  • Carboxylic acids react with metals above hydrogen in the reactivity series to give a salt plus hydrogen gas:

carboxylic acid + metal → metal carboxylate + hydrogen

  • Worked example: ethanoic acid with magnesium ribbon

2 CH3COOH(aq) + Mg(s) → (CH3COO)2Mg(aq) + H2(g)

  • The acid loses its acidic hydrogens to form the magnesium ethanoate salt
  • The gas given off can be tested with a lit splint — the characteristic squeaky pop confirms hydrogen

Common exam question

Observations with a reactive metal or a carbonate

Question: Give two observations that could be made when ethanoic acid reacts with magnesium, or state what you would observe when methanoic acid is added to sodium carbonate solution (1–2 marks).

Asked in 2 of the 23 papers. The first mark is effervescence (fizzing, bubbles). Both schemes ignore "a gas is given off", so describe the fizzing rather than the gas. The second observation with magnesium is that the metal gets smaller or disappears (dissolves is allowed). With a carbonate, the carbonate disappearing or dissolving is also allowed as the single observation.

Two marks need two different things you can see: the fizzing, then what happens to the solid.

Reaction with metal carbonates

  • Carboxylic acids react with carbonates to give a salt plus water plus carbon dioxide gas:

carboxylic acid + metal carbonate → metal carboxylate + water + carbon dioxide

  • Worked example: propanoic acid with sodium carbonate

2 CH3CH2COOH(aq) + Na2CO3(s) → 2 CH3CH2COONa(aq) + H2O(l) + CO2(g)

  • Worked example: methanoic acid with calcium carbonate

2 HCOOH(aq) + CaCO3(s) → (HCOO)2Ca(aq) + H2O(l) + CO2(g)

  • Visible features:
    • as carbon dioxide bubbles off
    • The carbonate dissolves into the acid solution
    • Confirming the gas: bubble it through limewater — the limewater turns milky, confirming CO2

Common exam question

Completing the equation with a metal or a carbonate

Question: Complete the symbol equation for ethanoic acid reacting with magnesium, or for methanoic acid reacting with sodium carbonate (2 marks).

Set in 2 of the 23 papers. Write the acid with its alkyl group first and −COOH last. For the magnesium reaction the first mark is for 2CH3COOH + Mg on the left (the molecular formula C2H4O2 is allowed, but a scrambled CH4COO is rejected) and the second is for H2 on the right. For a carbonate, one mark is for carbon dioxide and water, which stands even if their coefficients are wrong, and the other is for the salt written as 2HCOONa, since the question already prints two acid molecules. NaHCOO is allowed but NaCOOH is rejected: the sodium replaces the hydrogen on the oxygen, so the hydrogen left is the one on the carbon, whereas NaCOOH still shows the acid's O−H.

In the magnesium scheme multiples and fractions are allowed and state symbols are ignored even when wrong, so spend the time on the formulae rather than on (aq) and (g).

Exam tip

Testing for a carboxylic acid without an indicator

When a question rules out an indicator and asks for a chemical test for ethanoic acid in a mixture (2 marks), name the reagent before the observation. The first mark is for adding a carbonate (no name needed) or a named metal such as magnesium or zinc: "add a metal" loses the first mark, and a group 1 metal is rejected. The second mark is the effervescence, which only scores once you have said what you added: "add a metal; it fizzes" still earns one mark, but fizzing with nothing added scores zero. A gas test (a lighted splint pops for hydrogen, limewater turns milky for carbon dioxide) is accepted in place of the fizzing.

Reaction with metal hydroxides (neutralisation)

  • Like any acid, a carboxylic acid is neutralised by a metal hydroxide to give a salt plus water:

carboxylic acid + metal hydroxide → metal carboxylate + water

  • Worked example: ethanoic acid with sodium hydroxide

CH3COOH(aq) + NaOH(aq) → CH3COONa(aq) + H2O(l)

  • Sodium ethanoate (the salt) is fully soluble in water; the reaction is the same as for the inorganic acid–alkali reactions in topic 15

Why carboxylic acids are classed as weak acids

  • An aqueous carboxylic acid only partially dissociates — most of the acid molecules sit in solution as the un-dissociated −COOH form, with only a small fraction releasing H+
  • This makes carboxylic acids weak acids — a 1 mol dm−3 ethanoic acid solution has a pH of about 2.4, well above the pH 0–1 of a 1 mol dm−3 strong acid like HCl
  • All the reactions in this section still happen — they are simply slower than the equivalent reactions of HCl or H2SO4 at the same concentration

Quick check

5 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.

About 2 minutes

Build on this topic