4BI1

Excretion

Structures and Functions in Living Organisms · 6 question types

Exam Frequency Analysis

Past paper frequency (2018 to 2024)

This topic accounts for approximately 12% of your exam marks.

stable
High
Stable12%

The kidney and urea production appear regularly; dialysis is a common application question.

Each kidney has so much spare filtration capacity that a person can live a normal life with only one working kidney. But if both kidneys fail (a condition called renal failure), urea, water and ions accumulate in the blood within days, and the patient will die without treatment. There are two main treatments: and kidney transplant.

Dialysis (an artificial kidney)

Dialysis is a machine-based treatment that artificially performs the kidney's filtration job. The most common type is haemodialysis:

  1. Blood from one of the patient's arteries flows out of the body and into the dialysis machine.
  2. Inside the machine, the blood passes through a long network of partially permeable tubes (the artificial filter).
  3. Outside these tubes flows a dialysis fluid designed to match the normal levels of glucose, mineral ions and water that should be in healthy blood. The fluid contains no .
  4. Urea, excess ions and excess water diffuse out of the blood through the partially permeable membrane into the dialysis fluid (down a concentration gradient).
  5. Useful substances such as glucose and the right amount of ions stay in the blood, because the dialysis fluid already has the same concentration of these (no gradient → no net diffusion).
  6. The cleaned blood returns to a vein, back into the body.

A typical haemodialysis session lasts about 4 hours and is done three times a week at a hospital or clinic. Patients have to:

  • Watch their diet closely (especially salt and protein intake, since the machine is not as efficient as a real kidney at controlling these)
  • Limit how much fluid they drink between sessions
  • Accept the time commitment, the restrictions on travel, and the long-term risks of infection at the access point
Exam tip

How dialysis removes urea — the role of the concentration gradient

What comes up: explain how the dialyser is designed to increase the rate of removal of urea; or explain why urea moves from the blood into the dialysis fluid.

Write (two marks): (1) The dialysis fluid contains no urea, so there is a concentration gradient from the blood into the fluid. (2) Urea diffuses across the partially permeable membrane down this gradient (from high to low concentration).

Watch out: the mark scheme also accepts "the dialysis fluid is circulated/moving" as a way of maintaining the gradient — this is credited alongside "no urea in the fluid." Do not confuse this with how glucose and ions work: these are at the same concentration as normal blood plasma, so there is no net movement.

Dialysis keeps people alive, sometimes for many years, but it is not a cure. Without it, kidney failure is fatal within days.

Kidney transplant

A kidney transplant replaces the failed kidney with a healthy one from a donor. The donor can be:

  • A close living relative (who can donate one kidney and survive normally with the other)
  • A recently deceased person whose family has consented to organ donation

The surgery places the donor kidney into the lower abdomen, connects its blood vessels to the patient's arteries and veins, and connects its ureter to the patient's bladder. If everything works, the patient's body fluid balance returns to normal within days.

Advantages of a transplant over :

  • A working transplanted kidney is far more efficient than a dialysis machine
  • The patient does not need to attend the clinic three times a week
  • Diet and fluid restrictions can usually be relaxed
  • The cost per year is much lower in the long run

Disadvantages and challenges of a transplant:

  • The donor kidney is recognised by the recipient's immune system as foreign because its antigens do not match. The recipient's lymphocytes can attack the transplant, a process called rejection.
  • To reduce the chance of rejection, the donor must be a tissue match (the donor's antigens must be as close to the recipient's as possible). Close relatives are usually the best matches.
  • The recipient must take immunosuppressant drugs for life to dampen the immune response. This makes them more vulnerable to infections and some cancers.
  • There is a shortage of donor kidneys, and the waiting list is often long. Many patients spend years on dialysis before a suitable kidney becomes available.
Exam tip

Why a living relative is the best donor (tissue matching)

What comes up: suggest why a kidney from a close living relative reduces the risk of rejection (1–2 marks); or state advantages of a transplant over dialysis.

Write (rejection, 2 marks): (1) A close relative is likely to have the same or similar antigens (tissue type) as the recipient. (2) The recipient's immune system is therefore less likely to recognise the kidney as foreign, so there is less immune response / less rejection.

Watch out: the mark scheme credits "same tissue type / same blood type / similar genes / similar antigens" all as equivalent. For transplant advantages, the mark scheme credits "permanent / long-term treatment" and "can lead a normal life / better quality of life" — but it specifically says to ignore "dialysis takes a long time / inconvenient" as an advantage of transplant.

DialysisKidney transplant
What it doesFilters the blood with an external machineReplaces the failed kidney with a working donor kidney
How oftenThree sessions of around 4 hours per week, for lifeOne surgery; the new kidney then works continuously
Lifestyle restrictionsStrict diet and fluid limits, frequent hospital visitsRelatively normal life; daily immunosuppressant tablets
Donor needed?NoYes (living relative or deceased donor)
Risk of rejectionNone (no donor tissue involved)Yes; must be tissue-matched and take immunosuppressants
Long-term costHigh (machine time, staff time, transport)Lower in the long run, once surgery is paid for
Quality of lifeSubstantially reducedClose to normal if the kidney is not rejected