BiologyExam code: 4BI1

Diffusion, Osmosis & Active Transport

Structures and Functions in Living Organisms

Aim

To investigate how the concentration of an external sucrose solution affects osmosis in plant cells.

Principle

Cylinders of fresh potato contain plant cells with cytoplasm at some particular water concentration. If a cylinder is placed into a solution of higher water concentration (dilute sucrose, or distilled water), water moves into the potato by osmosis, and the cylinder gains mass. If it is placed in a solution of lower water concentration (concentrated sucrose), water moves out, and the cylinder loses mass. Somewhere in the middle there is a sucrose concentration that exactly matches the water concentration inside the potato cells, and the cylinder shows no change in mass.

Apparatus

  • A fresh potato
  • Cork borer (to cut equal-diameter cylinders)
  • Scalpel and ruler
  • Five or six sucrose solutions of known concentration (typically 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 and 1.0 mol/dm³)
  • Test tubes (one per solution) and a rack
  • Mass balance, accurate to at least 0.01 g
  • Paper towels
  • Forceps

Method

  1. Use the cork borer to cut 6 equal-diameter cylinders of potato from the same potato.
  2. Use the scalpel and ruler to trim each cylinder to the same length (around 3 cm works well).
  3. Blot each cylinder dry on a paper towel.
  4. Weigh each cylinder on the balance and record its initial mass.
  5. Place one cylinder into each test tube containing a different sucrose concentration. Note carefully which cylinder is in which tube.
  6. Leave the tubes for at least an hour (longer is better; 24 hours gives the cleanest results).
  7. Remove each cylinder, blot it dry with a paper towel, and reweigh it.
  8. Calculate the percentage change in mass for each cylinder using:

percentage change in mass = ((final mass − initial mass) ÷ initial mass) × 100

Variables

  • Independent variable: sucrose concentration (mol/dm³)
  • Dependent variable: percentage change in mass of the potato cylinder
  • Control variables: type of potato, age of potato, length and diameter of cylinder, volume of solution in each tube, time left in solution, temperature, how each cylinder is blotted before weighing

Exam tip

Method questions on the potato practical

The independent variable is what is in each tube: the solution, or its concentration. For another variable to control, name one the method has not already fixed, such as temperature or type of potato; time, volume of solution and mass of potato are ignored, since the method already fixes or measures them. Drying the cylinders before weighing removes surface liquid that would add to the mass, so the masses can be compared fairly ("to remove water" is ignored, as are "reliable" and "accurate"). A larger surface area means more contact between potato and solution, so osmosis is faster.

Plotting and using the results

Plot percentage change in mass on the y-axis against sucrose concentration on the x-axis. The result is a straight-ish line falling from positive values on the left (low sucrose, water gained) through zero (no change) and on to negative values on the right (high sucrose, water lost).

The point where the line crosses the x-axis (zero change in mass) gives the sucrose concentration that matches the water concentration inside the potato cells. This is a clever way of measuring something you cannot weigh directly.

Sample results table for potato cylinders in different sucrose concentrations, with the percentage change in mass calculated from the initial and final masses
Source: Investigating Diffusion & Osmosis by Save My Exams

Common exam question

Explaining the change in mass of the potato cylinders

Question: Explain the changes in mass of potato cylinders left in distilled water, in air and in sucrose solutions of different concentrations (3–5 marks).

Asked in 2 of the 23 papers. Pair each result with its cause: the cylinder in distilled water or dilute sucrose gains mass because water enters it, the one in concentrated sucrose loses mass because water leaves, the movement is by osmosis, and it runs from higher to lower water potential (from the dilute to the concentrated solution). Each of those is a separate mark, so "osmosis" without the direction, or the direction without the word osmosis, leaves a mark behind.

Where one concentration gives no change in mass, say that there is no net movement of water because that solution has the same water potential as the potato: each half is a credited point. A cylinder left in air changes little because no osmosis happens; any small loss is evaporation.

Why use percentage change rather than absolute change?

Different cylinders start at slightly different masses no matter how carefully you cut them. Using percentage change cancels out those starting differences and lets you compare cylinders fairly.

Worked example

Calculating percentage change in mass of a potato cylinder

A potato cylinder has an initial mass of 5.0 g. After sitting in a concentrated sucrose solution for one hour, its final mass is 4.4 g. Calculate the percentage change in mass.

Solution:

  • Change in mass = final mass − initial mass = 4.4 − 5.0 = −0.6 g
  • Percentage change = (change in mass ÷ initial mass) × 100
  • = (−0.6 ÷ 5.0) × 100 = −12%

The negative sign shows the cylinder lost mass: water moved out by osmosis into the more concentrated sucrose solution, and a positive answer would mean water moved in. Write the change in mass as a line of its own, because it earns a mark even if the division goes wrong, and a correct percentage with no working earns both marks.

Limitations

  • Cylinders may differ slightly in dimensions, which affects how much water can be exchanged. Solution: cut several cylinders for each sucrose concentration and take a mean.
  • Blotting before weighing has to be consistent. If one cylinder is more thoroughly dried than another, the mass reading is misleading.
  • The potato has to be the same age and freshness throughout. Older potatoes have already lost water and behave differently.

Quick check

5 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.

About 2 minutes

Build on this topic