BiologyExam code: 4BI1

Photosynthesis

Structures and Functions in Living Organisms

A limiting factor is something whose shortage slows down a process. In photosynthesis, the rate is set by whichever of the necessary inputs is in the shortest supply at that moment. Provide more of that factor and the rate climbs; the moment a different factor runs short, that one becomes the new limiting factor.

The three main limiting factors are:

  • Light intensity
  • Carbon dioxide concentration
  • Temperature

A fourth factor, availability (broadly, the number of chloroplasts in the leaf), can also limit the rate in specific situations.

Note: water is technically required for photosynthesis, but plants almost never run short of it for the reaction itself, because they lose far more water through transpiration than they use in photosynthesis. So water is not usually counted as a limiting factor.

Common exam question

Designing an investigation into a photosynthesis factor

Question: Design an investigation into how one factor (colour of light, carbon dioxide concentration, temperature or amount of sunlight) affects the rate of photosynthesis, crop yield or leaf size, with experimental details in full sentences (6 marks).

Set in 4 of the 23 papers, always the six-mark planning question, with the same seven points each time (any six score). Change the factor: at least two temperatures, three or more carbon dioxide concentrations, lamps of different colours, shaded and unshaded plots. Organism: plants of the same species, age, size and condition. Repeat and calculate a mean. Measure something specific, such as the volume of oxygen collected, bubbles counted, crop mass or number of fruits ("yield" alone was not enough; for leaf size, measure length, width or area), over a stated time. Then keep two other factors the same, one from temperature or light and one from mineral ions, pH, water or soil. One point per sentence, naming each variable precisely.

Light intensity

  • The brighter the light, the more energy chlorophyll can absorb, so the faster photosynthesis can run.
  • Plotting rate against light intensity gives a curve that rises steeply at first, then levels off when something else (CO₂ or temperature) becomes the bottleneck.
  • In a greenhouse, growers fit artificial lights to keep the rate high in winter and at night.

Common exam question

Explaining the effect of lamp distance on the bubble count

Question: Explain the effect of moving the lamp further from the pondweed on the number of bubbles per minute, or describe the relationship between light intensity and the bubble count (3–4 marks).

Asked in 3 of the 23 papers. For the explanation, write the chain in order: as the distance increases the light intensity falls; less light energy is absorbed; so the rate of photosynthesis falls; so less oxygen is released and fewer bubbles appear. The trend is the first mark, and "less light" alone does not earn the second, so say light intensity or light energy. For "describe the relationship", give the trend (more bubbles as light intensity rises), the shape (steepest at low light intensities) and the levelling off at high intensities, one mark each. When two carbon dioxide concentrations are compared, the extra marks are for the plateau, covered in the limiting-factor question below.

Carbon dioxide concentration

  • Atmospheric air is only about 0.04 % CO₂, so CO₂ is often the bottleneck for plants growing in still air.
  • Increasing the CO₂ around a plant boosts the rate of photosynthesis, until light or temperature catches up and becomes the new limit.
  • Commercial greenhouses sometimes pump in extra CO₂ (often from burning fuel) to push the rate up further.

Temperature

  • All of the chemical reactions inside the chloroplast are controlled by enzymes.
  • As temperature rises, the enzymes work faster (more kinetic energy, more successful collisions), so the rate of photosynthesis rises with temperature.
  • Above an optimum of about 30–40 °C, the enzymes start to denature: their active sites change shape, and the rate crashes.
  • This is why a graph of rate vs temperature for photosynthesis has the same peaked shape as for any enzyme-controlled process.

Common exam question

Explaining the effect of temperature on photosynthesis

Question: Explain the effect of increasing the temperature on the rate of photosynthesis, or on the time an indicator takes to change colour, from a graph or table (3 marks).

Asked in 3 of the 23 papers. First the trend: a higher temperature gives a faster rate of photosynthesis (in the indicator version, add that more carbon dioxide is removed, a separate mark). Second the enzyme reason: the molecules have more kinetic energy, so enzyme and substrate collide more often and more enzyme-substrate complexes form; "more enzyme activity" was accepted once too. A third mark can come from a limiting-factor point: at low temperatures temperature is the limiting factor; the rate levels off when light (at low light intensity) or carbon dioxide (at high) takes over; and extra carbon dioxide has little effect while temperature limits. No scheme gave a mark for denaturation, since no curve fell; keep it for a graph that drops after an optimum.

Chlorophyll availability

  • The more chloroplasts a leaf has, the more light it can absorb and the higher the maximum rate of photosynthesis.
  • Chlorophyll content can be reduced by:
    • Loss of leaves (e.g. in autumn, or due to disease)
    • Tobacco mosaic virus and other plant diseases that destroy chloroplasts
    • Magnesium deficiency in the soil (magnesium is part of every chlorophyll molecule, so without enough magnesium, the plant cannot make enough chlorophyll)
    • leaves, where some patches genuinely contain no chlorophyll at all
Graph of rate of photosynthesis against light intensity: the rate rises linearly at low light, then levels off to a constant plateau when another factor becomes limiting
Source: Factors Affecting the Rate of Photosynthesis by Save My Exams
Graph of rate of photosynthesis against carbon dioxide concentration: the rate rises linearly at low concentrations, then levels off to a constant plateau when another factor becomes limiting
Source: Factors Affecting the Rate of Photosynthesis by Save My Exams
Graph of rate of photosynthesis against temperature: the rate rises to an optimum as collisions between substrate and enzyme increase, then falls sharply as enzymes begin to denature
Source: Factors Affecting the Rate of Photosynthesis by Save My Exams

Reading a limiting-factor graph

A common exam question gives a graph that levels off at some maximum rate and asks what the limiting factor is:

  • If the x-axis is the factor you are changing (e.g. light intensity), then in the section where the line is going up, light intensity is the limiting factor.
  • In the section where the line has levelled off, the limiting factor is something else (one of the other two: CO₂, temperature, or chlorophyll). The exam expects you to name that other factor.
  • A graph with two lines at different temperatures (or CO₂ levels) shows which factor matters most: the line with the higher plateau is the one with the better-supplied "other" factor.

Common exam question

Explaining why the rate of photosynthesis levels off

Question: Explain the shape of a graph (or the pattern in a table) of the rate of photosynthesis against light intensity, carbon dioxide concentration or temperature, especially where the rate stops rising (2–4 marks).

Asked in 6 of the 23 papers. Two ideas carry the plateau marks: the rate no longer changes as the factor on the x-axis increases, because it is no longer the limiting factor and another factor now limits the rate. Name that factor (carbon dioxide concentration, temperature or chlorophyll); naming it can earn both marks. "Light is the limiting factor" written about the flat part scores nothing: light limits the rate only on the rising part, and saying so there is credited. With two curves on one graph, the lower one levels off sooner because its other factor (carbon dioxide concentration, temperature or light intensity) is lower, and extra carbon dioxide has little effect while temperature is limiting.

Quick check

5 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.

About 2 minutes

Build on this topic