PhysicsExam code: 4PH1

Cosmology

Astrophysics

What galactic redshift tells us

  • Two key observations from looking at galaxies all across the sky:
  1. Every distant galaxy is redshifted; they are all moving away from the Earth

  2. The further away a galaxy is, the greater the redshift, so the faster it is moving away

  • This relationship, distance proportional to recession speed, is known as Hubble's law
  • It tells us that the Universe is expanding uniformly. Each galaxy sees every other galaxy receding, just like dots on the surface of an inflating balloon

Why this is evidence for the Big Bang

The logic chain runs as follows:

  1. Distant galaxies show redshift → they are moving away from us
  2. The further away a galaxy, the bigger its redshift → distant galaxies are moving away faster
  3. If you rewind time, all galaxies must once have been very close together
  4. Rewind enough, and the entire Universe was concentrated in a single small region
  5. That fits the Big Bang picture: a hot dense beginning, followed by 14 billion years of expansion

The galactic redshift observations were one of the first major pieces of evidence for the Big Bang, first measured by Edwin Hubble in the 1920s, and refined ever since with better telescopes and supernova observations. The discovery of the CMB in 1964 then provided the second, independent piece of evidence.

What galactic redshift does NOT mean

  • The galaxies are not moving through space away from a centre. Instead, space itself is expanding between them, carrying them apart (the balloon analogy)
  • There is no single point in space that the Universe is expanding from; every point is moving away from every other point
  • The Earth is not at the centre of the Universe. Any observer in any galaxy would see all the other galaxies redshifted by the same amount, just as every dot on the inflating balloon sees all the other dots receding

Common exam question

Explaining why red-shift is evidence for the Big Bang

Question: Explain how the red-shift of galaxies, or more red-shift for more distant galaxies, is evidence for the Big Bang or an expanding universe (2–4 marks).

Asked in 5 of the 24 papers, every time on Paper 2. Each link of the chain can score: light from the galaxies is red-shifted, so they are moving away from us; the further a galaxy is, the greater its red-shift, so the faster it recedes (quoting Hubble's law is accepted); so all the galaxies are moving apart: the universe is expanding; so it must once have been at a single point. Two schemes marked "expanding" and "single point" separately.

Stick to the observation given: one scheme ignored any mention of the CMB; another ignored the single point, the expansion and the Big Bang itself, giving its two marks for double red-shift meaning double speed, then larger speed meaning larger distance (or galaxies moving apart). Two schemes condoned "stars" for galaxies; one rejected "planets".

Quick check

4 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.

About 2 minutes

Build on this topic