Market Failure & Externalities
Allocation of Resources
Merit and demerit goods are a different kind of market failure, arising from or misjudged personal benefits, often combined with externalities.
Merit goods
A merit good is under-consumed in a free market because consumers underestimate the benefits of consuming it (or because it generates positive externalities).
Examples: education, healthcare, vaccinations, fresh fruit and vegetables, pension contributions.
Two reasons the free market under-provides them:
- Information failure. Consumers do not fully realise how much they will gain from the good. Many young adults underestimate the value of higher education; many people skip flu vaccinations because they underestimate the personal protection it offers.
- Positive externalities. Education and vaccination produce benefits for other people (a better-educated workforce, herd immunity), and these are not captured by the price the consumer pays.
Government response: subsidies, free or subsidised state provision, compulsory consumption (e.g. compulsory schooling), and information campaigns.
Exam tip
Policies for a merit good must raise its consumption
When you analyse how a government could encourage people to consume a merit good, use measures that act on the merit good itself and follow each one through: a subsidy or a cut in indirect tax lowers its price and makes it affordable; information campaigns correct people's underestimate of its benefits; regulation can make it compulsory, as with school attendance; the state can provide it free; a maximum price makes it cheaper but risks a shortage. Taxing or banning a demerit good earns credit only when you tie it to people switching to a merit good.
Demerit goods
A demerit good is over-consumed in a free market because consumers underestimate the harm of consuming it (or because it generates negative externalities).
Examples: cigarettes, alcohol, recreational drugs, junk food, sugary drinks, gambling.
Two reasons the free market over-provides them:
- . Consumers do not fully realise the future health damage, addiction risk, or social harm.
- Negative externalities. Consumption affects others: passive smoking, drink-driving, healthcare costs paid by the state.
Government response: indirect taxes (sin taxes), regulations (minimum legal age, advertising bans, packaging warnings), outright bans on the worst products, and education campaigns.
Common exam question
Telling public, merit and demerit goods apart
Question: Pick the public, merit or demerit good, or say why the state provides some goods (1 mark, multiple choice).
Set in 6 of the 13 multiple-choice papers. A public good is non-rival and non-excludable, so firms cannot charge users and will not supply it: the keyed reason for state provision. A demerit good is more harmful to its consumers than they realise, so it is over-consumed; a merit good is under-consumed because people underestimate its benefits.
Wrong options swap labels: education, healthcare or railways as public goods (users can be charged; defence is keyed); merit, free or economic goods as what markets cannot provide; a demerit good defined by private costs above social costs, or by external benefits; defence or unemployment benefit as merit goods; providing demerit goods as a government role.
Asked in 1 of the 11 structured papers, as 4 marks on merit versus public goods: a feature and example of each (education; defence or street lighting).
A merit / demerit good is not the same as a . Merit goods are usually rival (one person's healthcare appointment uses up a doctor's time) and excludable (a school can refuse to enrol non-payers). The two failures sometimes overlap but are conceptually distinct.
The labels "merit" and "demerit" are descriptive, not moral judgements. The terms describe under- or over-consumption, not whether the good is good or bad in any absolute sense.
Quick check
4 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.