EconomicsExam code: 0455

Market Failure & Externalities

Allocation of Resources

Two intervention tools that need separate diagrams.

Maximum price (price ceiling)

A maximum price is a legal price cap below the free-market equilibrium. Sellers cannot legally charge more.

  • Quantity supplied contracts (less profitable at a lower price).
  • Quantity demanded extends (cheaper, so more is wanted).
  • The result is a shortage (excess demand) at the legal maximum.
A maximum price P(max) set below the equilibrium P(e): quantity supplied contracts to Qs while quantity demanded extends to Qd, so the gap Qs to Qd is excess demand — a shortage
Source: Solutions to Market Failure: Maximum & Minimum Prices by Save My Exams

Common exam question

Drawing a maximum or minimum price

Question: Draw a demand and supply diagram with a maximum price set below equilibrium, define a minimum price, or analyse how either control causes disequilibrium (2–6 marks).

Asked in 2 of the 11 structured papers. The drawing earns four marks: price and quantity axes, labelled demand and supply curves, a price line below the equilibrium, and quantity demanded shown greater than quantity supplied (a correctly marked shortage is also accepted). A minimum price is defined as a price set by the government (one mark) above the equilibrium price (the second). The specimen mark scheme's 6-mark Analyse gives a mark for placing each price, then credits the chains: price falls, demand extends, supply contracts, shortage; price rises, demand contracts, supply extends, surplus.

Set in 2 of the 13 multiple-choice papers. A maximum price cuts the quantity traded as well as the price, because firms supply less; it counts as regulation, not fiscal, monetary or supply-side policy.

Used to protect consumers in essential markets: rent controls in a housing crisis, price caps on essential medicines, fuel price caps during shortages.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Lower prices protect low-income consumersShortages mean some buyers go without
Stabilises markets during emergenciesBlack markets may emerge (illegal resale at higher prices)
Limits exploitation in rental and essential-goods marketsReduces producer incentive to invest in supply

Common exam question

Discussing a maximum price

Question: Explain why a government controls the price of an essential good, or discuss whether it should set a maximum price on a product such as housing (2–8 marks).

Asked in 2 of the 11 structured papers. For: a necessity becomes affordable, which reduces poverty and inequality and leaves households money for other needs; a cap also stops a monopoly using its power to push the price up. Against: set below the equilibrium it creates a shortage, because firms supply less and may cut quality to protect their profits; informal markets spring up at higher prices; and a cap set above the equilibrium price changes nothing. The 8-mark version is marked by levels, so develop both sides.

Minimum price (price floor)

A minimum price is set above the free-market equilibrium. Sellers cannot legally charge less.

  • Quantity supplied extends (more profitable at a higher price).
  • Quantity demanded contracts (more expensive, so less is bought).
  • The result is a surplus (excess supply) at the legal minimum.
A minimum price P(min) set above the equilibrium P(e): quantity demanded contracts to Qd while quantity supplied extends to Qs, so the gap Qd to Qs is excess supply — a surplus
Source: Price controls by Save My Exams

Used to support producers (agricultural floor prices) or to discourage consumption of a demerit good (minimum unit pricing for alcohol). The national minimum wage is a minimum price in the labour market designed to protect workers from low pay.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Producers receive a guaranteed incomeSurplus output may need to be bought up by the government
Reduces consumption of demerit goodsEncourages over-production and waste
Minimum wage raises pay of the lowest paidHigher costs may lead firms to lay off workers

Quick check

4 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.

About 2 minutes

Build on this topic