Fiscal & Monetary Policy
Government and the Macroeconomy
Fiscal policy is the government's use of its budget (its decisions on taxes and public spending) to influence the economy.
The government budget
The government budget is a plan of the government's revenue (mostly from taxes) and its spending over a period, usually a year.
The budget has two sides:
- Government revenue (mostly tax): income tax, corporation tax, VAT, excise duty, national insurance, capital gains tax, and so on.
- Government spending: public services (health, education), welfare (pensions, benefits), capital projects (roads, hospitals), and debt interest.
Comparing the two gives the budget position:
A budget surplus is when government revenue is greater than spending. A budget deficit is when government spending is greater than revenue, so the government has to borrow to fund the gap.
The size of a deficit or surplus is simply the gap between the two figures: budget balance = total revenue − total spending. A positive answer is a surplus; a negative answer is a deficit. Most governments run a small persistent deficit.
Common exam question
What changes tax revenue and the budget balance
Question: Identify or analyse why a government's tax revenue rises or falls, or discuss whether a budget deficit is likely (2–6 marks).
Asked in 2 of the 11 structured papers. Link each tax to what it is levied on, one mark per step: more jobs and incomes bring in more income tax, more spending more indirect tax, higher profits more corporation tax and more imports more tariff revenue, so a recession cuts them all. For a deficit, weigh both sides: rising unemployment (more benefits, less income tax), a growing population (pensions, healthcare, education) and debt interest from past deficits make one likely; a growing labour force and rising GDP (more taxpayers, fewer benefit claims) make it less likely.
The same idea is set in 1 of the 13 multiple-choice papers. Take revenue minus spending each year: spending of 72bn to 18bn to $9bn, not a surplus.
Reasons for government spending
Governments spend on several broad areas, each with its own purpose:
- Public services such as healthcare and education, to provide merit goods that would be under-provided by the market.
- Welfare and benefits such as pensions and unemployment benefit, to redistribute income and reduce poverty.
- Infrastructure such as roads, railways and ports, to lower firms' costs and support long-run growth.
- Defence, law and order, to provide public goods that markets will not supply.
- Debt interest, the unavoidable cost of past borrowing.
The way the government splits its spending across these areas affects growth, inequality and the other macroeconomic aims.
Common exam question
Should the government spend more on one area
Question: Discuss whether a government should spend more (or less) on an area such as healthcare, housing, renewable energy or pensions, or analyse what that spending could achieve (6–8 marks).
Asked in 6 of the 11 structured papers. Give the area's own case (healthcare is a merit good the poor may not afford; renewable energy cuts external costs), then the wider one: more total demand, output and jobs. Against: the opportunity cost, higher taxes or borrowing and a budget deficit, inflation near full employment, and a private sector that might do it better. For a cut, such as smaller state pensions, the sides swap: a smaller deficit against lower living standards, more poverty and less total demand.
The 6-mark data-response version credits up to 4 marks a side; the 8-mark version is levels-marked, and its top level needs both sides developed. An Analyse answer built on one area is capped at 4 marks, so develop two.
Expansionary fiscal policy
Expansionary lifts aggregate demand by raising government spending or cutting taxes (or both).
The mechanism: higher spending puts money directly into the economy (more infrastructure projects, higher welfare payments). Lower taxes leave households and firms with more disposable income, which they spend. Both channels raise aggregate demand (AD), which lifts real GDP and reduces unemployment.
Expansionary policy is used when the economy is in a recession or growing too slowly. The trade-off: if used too aggressively, it can trigger demand-pull inflation (topic 13).
Contractionary fiscal policy
Contractionary fiscal policy lowers aggregate demand by cutting government spending or raising taxes (or both).
The mechanism is the mirror image: higher taxes reduce disposable income; lower spending withdraws money from the economy. AD falls, which slows inflation but also slows growth and may raise unemployment.
Contractionary policy is used when inflation is too high or when the government deficit has become unsustainably large.
Limitations of fiscal policy
Fiscal policy has four main limitations:
- Time lags. Tax changes and new spending take months to years to feed through. Recognising the problem, passing the law, and waiting for the effect can leave fiscal policy acting after the economy has already moved on.
- Political constraints. Tax rises and spending cuts are unpopular with voters. Governments often avoid them even when they are economically right.
- The cost of funding it. A deficit has to be paid for by borrowing, and borrowing adds to debt interest, one of the main areas of government spending. Money that goes on servicing past debt is money that cannot be spent on other priorities in future budgets.
- Imperfect information. The government does not always know exactly where the economy is in the cycle, so its fiscal response may arrive late or be the wrong size.
Common exam question
Whether fiscal policy can achieve an aim
Question: Discuss whether fiscal policy can achieve an aim such as full employment or less poverty, or analyse how government spending and unemployment are related (5–8 marks).
Asked in 3 of the 11 structured papers. For: more spending or lower taxes raise total demand, so firms hire and cyclical unemployment falls; spending on education, training and job information makes workers more skilled and mobile; benefits, and spending paid for by progressive taxes, reduce poverty. Against: the change may be too small, weak confidence can stop spending, tax cuts can be inflationary and benefits can weaken the incentive to work. Turning a "might" point round earns nothing on the other side. With data, state the relationship, quote figures showing it and explain the exception.
The same idea is set in 4 of the 13 multiple-choice papers. Both halves of a paired option must push total demand the same way, and a cut in direct taxes raises demand and supply together.
Quick check
5 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.