Computer ScienceExam code: 0984

Robotics

Automated and Emerging Technologies

Many of these have appeared in the application-specific tables above; here is the general view.

Advantages

AdvantageWhy it matters
SafetyRobots can do dangerous jobs (bomb disposal, deep-sea inspection, radioactive cleanup, factory welding) that would put humans at serious risk
Repeatability and precisionA robot performs the same action with the same accuracy every time; ideal for assembly, surgery and laboratory tasks
24/7 operationRobots do not need breaks, sleep, food, holidays or pay
ProductivityTasks are completed faster, with less rework and fewer mistakes
StrengthRobots can lift heavy loads humans could not safely handle
Working in extreme environmentsRobots can operate at very high or low temperatures, in vacuum, underwater, or in space
Frees humans for higher-value workRoutine tasks are automated; humans can focus on tasks needing creativity or judgement

Disadvantages

DisadvantageWhy it matters
High upfront costDesigning, buying and installing robots is expensive; ROI may take years
Ongoing maintenanceRobots need regular service, software updates and occasional repair
Job displacementRoles disappear when their tasks are automated; workers may need re-training
InflexibilityMost robots only handle the situations they have been programmed for; novel scenarios may baffle them
Cyber-security riskNetworked robots can be hacked; consequences range from production downtime to physical harm
Lack of human judgementRobots cannot weigh ethical considerations or react to unusual situations the way a person can
Safety risks to humans nearbyIndustrial robots are powerful; collisions with workers can cause injury, so they often need cages or careful safety zones
De-skilling of the workforceIf a robot does the skilled work, fewer humans learn the trade; the skills may be lost over generations

Exam tip

Explaining the drawbacks of using a robot

Tie each drawback to the scenario. For a self-driving tractor the credited points were high set-up and maintenance costs (skilled experts needed to fix it), the farmer needing costly reskilling, deskilling of workers, fewer employees and so unemployment, a malfunction (failing to stop for a person) and the expense of changing what it does. Each drawback is a point and a linked reason or consequence is another, so three marks can come from three drawbacks or from fewer, each developed. Buying, maintaining and changing its function are separate cost points, so name the cost rather than writing "it is expensive".

Ethical and legal questions

Robotics, combined with artificial intelligence (topic 17), raises a set of harder questions that go beyond simple pros and cons:

  • Accountability: if a robot makes a decision that injures someone, who is responsible: the manufacturer, the programmer, the operator, or the owner?
  • Safety: how do we test a robot's behaviour exhaustively to prove it is safe before deploying it?
  • Algorithmic bias: if a smart robot was trained on data that contained bias, it can repeat or amplify that bias in its decisions.
  • Legal liability: existing laws were written for human actors; rules for autonomous machines are still being developed.
  • Employment: as more jobs are automated, society has to decide how to support workers whose roles disappear.

These are open questions, not questions with one right answer.

Quick check

4 short questions on this note. See what has stuck, and where to look if something hasn't.

About 2 minutes

Build on this topic